VB Manufacturing, Phoenix House, Tern Hill, Market Drayton, Shropshire, TF9 3PX
       
TEL:                                      FAX:                                    E-Mail:
 
+44 (0)1630 637375                          +44 (0)1630 637377                         
sales@hegner.co.uk

Home
Hegner Machines
VB36 Lathes
Multistar
Abrasives & Oils

      Designers View

Insights from the designer
             -Nigel Voisey explains the VB concept:

Designers View
Ex Works spec
Bearing spec
Controls
Transmission
Tailstocks
Toolrests
Work Holding
Accessories
Videos
Free Video
Gallery
Order a VB36

    As a woodworking journalist through the late sixties and on into the nineties, it was not my way to look for faults and shortcomings in the machines I was assigned to review, but simply to report honestly on what I found. I always hoped to find the best but was disappointed that so many manufacturers knew surprisingly little about how the machines they made were actually used.
     I came into woodworking from an engineering background and often made suggestions as to ways in whch machines I found fault with could be improved. More and more of my time was spent in original design work for various manufacturers. The main problem was that manufacturing costs placed severe constraints on the choices that could be made. Market forces dictated that "ideal" solutions rarely saw the light of day, that is, if such changes made machines considerably more expensive than outwardly similar competitors. By and large, the woodworking world at user level is too thinly spread for news of product limitations to become shared knowledge. When a newcomer to woodturning experiences problems with a particular cut, he more likely to blame himself than to recognise the limitations of the equipment he is using.
    I had settled for the fact that I was not going to find a way of removing accountants from the design loop or changing the world when Roger Buse asked me to design a lathe that I would be truly happy with. Whatever the final cost turned out to be, we would adjust our market expectations on the basis of that figure rather than design with an initial, choice-limiting cost in mind. I was delighted!
    By the mid eighties I think I had used every lathe available on the world market. None of them, not one, offered more than a basic means to make the wood go round. I still find it incredible that until very recently the most popular lathe for top woodturners had just four speeds which had to be changed, more or less blind, through a hatch at ankle level in the pedestal whilst, at the same time, supporting the weight of the motor!

NO NOISE, NO WEAR, NO "FLOAT"

    Another limitation imposed by cost considerations in the above case  (and with most other lathe designs) is seen in the choice of bearings. Although transmuted into a virtue by marketing men, ball bearings are not the ideal support for heavily loaded shafts running at low speeds. Radial ball bearing assemblies and, to a lesser extent, roller bearings, are specified for reasons of economy as they are relatively cheap to buy and demand far less rigid engineering tolerances in the machining of the housings in which they are fitted than precision plain bearings. However, where extreme load carrying capability is called for, especially at low rotational speeds, plain bearings are the natural choice because they effectively eliminate metal-to-metal contact at the bearing interface. Such bearings often have the capacity to carry loads far in excess of the actual machine frame strength. (The Rolls Royce RB211 turbine developing 38,000 shaft horse power has plain mainshaft bearings lubricated by compressed air. Industrial machines from watchmaker's lathes to micron accurate CNC grinders also use plain bearings.)

The VB's precision bearings cradle the mainshaft without ever allowing metal- to-metal contact.

    Consider the total silence with which these bearings do their job; the potentially perfect rotational concentricity they provide (effectively zero shaft float);  mind-boggling load carrying capacity, and a life expectancy far exceeding one's own, and you can understand why this is an essential requirement for the "perfect" lathe.

CLEAR TOOL PATH ACCESS

   The traditional centre lathe design, which is the basis for virtually all modern lathes, came into existence when turners thought that turning off-centre legs was an adventure. These machines were not made to assist today's turners with the sort of shapes and hollow forms that they often want to create. Although with skill and care such work can be done on them, it generally entails bending and straining at unnatural angles to direct the tool. Swivel head lathes make access easier, at least from the front, but then of course the tailstock cannot be used for initial support in working on deep, hollow forms, or to hold "finished" work between centres to remove evidence of chucking etc.
    Contrast the experience of making the cuts required for this sort of work with your weight balanced directly over your feet; elbows pulled into your sides to gain maximum control inertia from your body and you will never want to turn any other way. The new lathe was to have this requirement as another essential feature of its final shape. Vertically sheer casting and cabinet faces on the turner's side of the VB mean that even when approaching the work from behind,
that is, alongside the headstock, it is possible to stand within 6" of the turning axis. The rounded nose profile of the casting where the mainshaft emerges clears even this small obstruction that might otherwise limit potential avenues of tool presentation from the rear of the work.
    For the same reasons, the (optional) tailstock is offset so that it can be brought into use whenever required without obstructing tool access. The turner can stand directly in front of the work at its outer end with the tailstock in place and enjoy the same freedom of approach. All of this of course is only useful provided the tool rest itself can be positioned so as to eliminate over-reaching and excessive tool overhangs. Here again the VB is unique in allowing complete freedom of movement for the toolrest assembly around workpieces of up to 36" in diameter by 30" in length. (Much larger projects can be turned on the standard VB with the simple addition of the "Free Standing Toolrest")

ACCESSIBLE CONTROLS

    Being able to work freely from the front, side or back of a workpiece that might measure anything up to 7' 6" in diameter (over 2 metres) highlights another essential requirement — that controls should always be comfortably to hand, or foot, when ON/OFF functions are needed.  Obviously fixed location controls cannot meet this need. VB controls are accordingly fed through a 24volt spur lead to a magnetically backed box that can be stuck on any flat metal surface precisely where needed. Switches are provided for starting and stopping the lathe; running in forward or reverse (useful for sanding, applying sealers and polishing); choosing fast or slow acceleration and braking times; and setting or varying the speed by means of a ten revolution dial. (Changing the speed over such a high number

of dial revolutions means that the speed can never be inadvertently knocked to a dangerously high setting — not an uncommon occurrence with lever or "coarse" dial speed change systems.)
    If totally hands-free START/STOP functions are called for, such as when deep hollowing through the mouth of a narrow necked vessel, an additional 24volt spur is provided within the standard specification for connection of a footswitch at any time. The addition of a footswitch does not interfere with the normal functioning of the hand control unit.

SMOOTHEST POWER DELIVERY

    One of the problems encountered by those who first tried to give that lathe mentioned previously (the one with the ankle level belt change) electronic variable speed was that the belt slipped at low motor speed settings. A drive pulley diameter that has been calculated to transmit the full motor power at normal motor speed (say 1425rpm) loses transmissive efficiency as the motor speed is reduced. The motor will keep turning but the belt will slip. For variable speed lathes, the drive pulley diameters must be re-calculated in line with a formula that describes exactly how much power each rib of a belt will transmit at the lowest envisaged motor speed, andaccordingly by how much the drive pulley diameters need to be increased.   
    Adoption of this principal in the VB design involved a major cost that it would obviously have been much cheaper to compromise — but this would have been to negate the whole point of what we set out to do. The low speedratio of the VB's three pulley steps is therefore driven through a fifteen rib, 60mm diameter pulley. To achieve the desired 4:1 reduction  for best gearing(and to keep the motor turning at a healthy speed when the lowest setting is used ), the final drive pulley had to be machined to 240mm diameter. This is about twice the diameter and three times the width of the comparable pulley on any other proprietary

lathe for woodturning — and, when the calculations are done, about ten times the cost! Also, we had it in mind that the system needed to be adequate for the larger than standard motors that the VB can be fitted with, and without the need for anything more than moderate belt tension.
    Belt tension is applied through a crank handle on the outside of the headstock and held by screw adjustment rather than friction. This allows tension to be finely tuned, adjusted and set with the lathe running
¥ eliminating the variations and uncertainties of friction held systems.
    The electronics package is likewise the most sophisticated available. It allows us to pre-set more than 30 performance parameters to ensure that power delivery and final drive rotations are the smoothest imaginable. Even under operating extremes of free-running or heavy braking , forces are continually monitored and power automatically and instantaneously adjusted to keep the work turning at precisely the pre-selected speed.

LOAD SECURITY

    I gave the work mounting arrangement a lot of thought. Turners had become used to the 1½" x 6tpi thread as the one that, at professional and other serious turner level, would enable them to continue using most of the expensive chucks and and other threaded fittings they already had. Yet, from an engineering standpoint, it was very clear that this was far less than ideal for the VB. The imposition of a threaded fitting between the lathe and the workpiece would result in a measurable loss of turning concentricity. We wanted the same sort of run-out test figures that would be acceptable in a top quality engineering lathe.
     We also had to consider the risks of a heavy load unscrewing itself  from a threaded mounting due to its own momentumduring a braking cycle. Then there was the occasional need to be able to safely reverse the drive for various reasons (including left-handed turning!). We finally decided on a modified bayonet fitting where the chuck or faceplate effectively becomes an integral part, or extension of the mainshaft with no weak or flexible links due to an interposing thread.
     To continue using existing chucks (to better effect than ever before in fact), most accessory manufacturers offer an alternative backplate or body for their chucks with the VB fitting. Alternatively if you need to retain the original lathe thread, a range of thread adaptors are available which lock directly onto the VB mandrel nose allowing your chucks to be used in the conventional way.

Secure "bayonet receiver" for VB fittings

Thread adaptor for other fittings

    When making thread adaptors we also match the original lathe's Morse Taper so that all other original fittings such as drive centres and M.T. arbor drill chucks will fit.

MOST ACCOMODATING TO INDIVIDUAL TURNING STYLES & PROJECT NEEDS

    Many of the lathes I used in my reviewing days had toolrests that prohibited the use of anything other than an "overhand" grip. I generally like to turn with my lead hand as close as possible to the bearing edge of the toolrest with the palm facing up to cradle the tool.. I therefore wanted to ensure that no matter what style of grip a turner favoured, he or she would be happy with the VB rests. Also, there are times when a conventional "T" rest does not offer the particular sort of

support that is required — for example when the tool needs to be supported close to its tip whilst up to 1 metredeep inside a hollow form. All of these situations are catered for within the VB system.

Conventional 'T' pattern toolrest

The XDHR Deep Hollowing Rest

DESIGNED TO CARRY THE HEAVIEST & LIGHTEST OF WORK

   Because of its exceptionally precise turning characteristics, theVB is unmatched in its ability to allow the turner to produce the most delicate forms entirely free from the limiting effects of vibration or unwanted shaft float.
    At the other end of the scale, the VB brings you virtually unlimited potential for handling the heaviest of eccentrically shaped pieces. This is partly due to the mainshaft design and bearing configuration that I mentioned earlier. The VB's mainshaft is 500mm in length with an external bearing separation of 400mm. This provides an adequate counter-leverage factor to ensure that the headstock casting is relatively unstressed by the huge dynamic forces that can be placed on it.
    To better visualise this, imagine that the rear bearing of the shaft is replaced by your

Perfect rotational stability facilitates finest tool work

hand. The force you would feel from a static load on the spindle nose would be pushing your hand up and you would exert proportionate downwards pressure to counteract it. The front bearing would be the fulcrum point of the system. A short shaft would severely limit the possible weight of the overhanging load. Conversely, it is easy to see that if the length of the shaft is increased, the forces being focused through the casting where it supports the front bearing are increasingly being directed in the plane of its maximum strength and greater loads can be carried.
    In this picture the mainshaft is acting as a beam and its strength must be calculated to span the gap between the bearings without flexing under any load envisaged. Another fact that now becomes obvious is that a lathe's real performance potential cannot be judged simply by turning a heavy disc — impressive though that may appear. Overhang of the load beyond the front bearing is the factor that will really test the engineering soundness of a lathe's design.
    The VB's shaft is turned from EN8 steel (extremely tough

These "sea flowers" have hollow centres and with a wall thickness of about 2mm weigh in at less than an ounce!

andwith about twice the tensile strength of mild steel) and ground to its finished diameter of 60mm. The bearing journals are then electrically hard-chromed in final preparation for their virtually endless working life. To say that no other woodworking lathe even remotely approaches this specification is no exaggeration; it is an indisputable fact.

      During a recent International Woodworking and Woodturning Exhibition at the NEC, Birmingham, the VB was used to turn a trunk section of wet oak measuring 26" in diameter by 46" in length.  The hall owners would not let us drill their floor to secure the lathe so the work was done with the lathe free standing! The standard tailstock was fitted to prevent the lathe toppling forward under the 700lbs overhanging load, but the entire job was finished without support from the tail centre at any stage and without any additional subframe to extend the VB's natural footprint. You may never want to turn anything of this size but it's nice to know that the features which enable pieces of that description to be carried without strain are the same ones that contribute to Melvyn Firmager's production of his incredibly delicate and fragile "Sea Flowers".

   Another piece, this time commissioned by the "Worshipful Company of Turners" for the 400th anniversary of the guild, was turned at the Stoneleigh Exhibition in September this year by Stephen Cooper. (Finished weight: ¼ ton approx. Height 4'6" by 4' diameter.)

"FUTURE-PROOF"
    It took about three years to design the VB and another two to get it into production. In the seven years since then it has been tested beyond the limits I had in mind when I was sitting in front of my drawing board, but has successfully met every challenge. Future developments that may come from ideas from users (the "Bennison Adaptor" for example) or new technology will always be introduced in a way that can be applied to existing machines. Owners can be confident that a VB lathe will never be obsolete but will always be "upgradable" to meet the very latest specification.

Previous Page

Next Page

Technology Supplies Logo
 

HEGNER U.K.
Phoenix House, Tern Hill, Market Drayton, Shropshire, TF9 3PX, England.

SALES: +44 (0)1630 637375
TECHNICAL: +44 (0)1630 637376
FAX: +44 (0)1630 637377
E-Mail: sales@hegner.co.uk